
Read part 1 of ‘Calibrate your Expectations: What do we want the most from the Colorado Rapids? Pt. 1’ here.
…
Whelp, the Rapids didn’t make the playoffs. Again. Seven years out the last ten, that’s been the result, in a league where having just-under a .500 record will get you to the playoffs. It’s become entrenched mediocrity. That’s the brand now.1
So I guess it’s really kind perfect that we’re looking at the bottom of half of the ‘calibrating expectations’ tier chart now. We’ve been let down. We can start to ruminate on other possible outcomes and letdowns that this team might have in store for us.
This is a mix of ‘that would be a suboptimal choice’ and BURN WITH FIRE. DO NOT WANT.
Starting at the C-Tier.
C-Tier
Having KSE Sell the Team
I know some of you would put this as your S-Tier. And, look, I see the logic. I’ve been a ranter and raver on KSE’s lack of investment or sheer neglect of the Rapids for a decade. Sure, KSE seem uninterested in investing real money to make the team excellent or the stadium nice or the fan experience the best possible. And yes, it does seem that of Stan and Josh Kroenke’s seven pro teams2, the Rapids seem to rank sixth. So KSE should sell the team to any investor and clearly this is an S-tier, top priority. QED.
Wait, I lost my train of thought in the pro-sell-the-team line of thinking. No, right, there’s a reason it’s C-Tier.
The reason is: there are worse owners.
There’s some bad team owners out there - worse than KSE. Owners that don’t have a single team winning trophies (Rams, Arsenal). Owners that are either horrifically immoral, incompetent, mercurial, or simply see their team as a mine-able resource to be stripped of parts or used as a venture capital shell-game to withdraw funds, load with debt, and abandon. Dick Monfort and the Rockies. Dejphon Chansiri and Sheffield Wednesday. Joey Saputo and CF Montreal. Dan Borislaw and magicjack FC [ you probably didn’t know about this one - it’s crazypants]. Donald Sterling and the LA Clippers.
Sure, the ‘it can always be worse’ argument is a weird one, but I stand by in the sense that I believe, with the right economic circumstances and a few lucky signings or academy products, the Rapids could be a top-six club in MLS, even if KSE doesn’t adjust course. The team could also get sold to a Phoenix hedge fund that wants to move it to a Native American reservation and turn it into a casino. If there were a clear billionaire in the city of Denver with a love of footie, I’d feel different. Until that guy materializes, I’m ambivalent about a miracle owner that would deliver the Rapids to titletown.
Flip a young successful player to Europe, again
Normally I think most teams would say ‘This is a good thing! They get to grow, we get cash to spend. Win-win.’ Vancouver and Antonio Davies. NYRB and Matt Miazga. SKC and Gianluco Busio.
Except, we’ve been there before with both Moïse Bombito and Lucas Herrington, not to mention Sam Vines and Cole Bassett before that. It hasn’t made the Rapids better. It means they get a bunch of money, and then spend some of that money on replacements. But it doesn’t feel like it buys the caliber of player that wins trophies. None of those sales resulted in a better season for the team afterward. The Rapids still made the playoffs in 2024 after they sold Bombito. But then they stumbled down the stretch and got hammered in the first round of the playoffs in the best-two-out-of-three by an aggregate score of 9-1. Wouldn’t they have been better off keeping Bombito, at least for six more months?
The jury is still out to some extent on the effect of selling Lucas Herrington – and whether some clever moves like letting Noah Cobb step up and buying Morgan Whitaker and Sayed Abu Farchi and Youssef Maziz with some of the cash will be a net gain in exchange. But it feels like we’ve been here before, and it didn’t end well.
Lock up Rob Holding on a 1 year extension
I’ve already said that ‘getting a better, younger CB’ for cash is the best option. But I don’t mind getting Holding back for a year - although with the next calendar starting effectively now because the sprint season, I think a contract renewal has to be 18 month, calibrated to end June 30. (UPDATE: The Sun is reporting that Holding is headed back to England to play for Sheffield United. So I guess the Rapids have no choice but to go with the B-Tier option: bring in an upgrade.)
Find that Perfect Center Forward
Should this higher? Maybe. I guess it’s lower because I don’t actually think, with the players on the roster, that center forward is what ails the team. Also, they had a pretty damn good CF in Rafa Navarro, and somehow that didn’t really make this team good. So the Rapids need to focus on other areas first, I think.
D-Tier
Spend another transfer window being ‘Distressed Assets FC’
For those who haven’t followed the pod or read the substack for a long time, there was a period when the Rapids seemed enthusiastic about collecting the broken toys from other MLS teams and saying ‘surely, he’s due for a rebound. Let’s buy low. It didn’t work with Team X, but…’

That’s Kevin Cabrál, and Omir Fernandez, and maybe Ted Ku DiPietro, and Aboubar Keita, and Sidnei Tavares. That’s Steven Beitashour and Gyasi Zardes from the 2022 team, and Nicolas Benezet from 2020.
It hits sometimes, which is why this isn’t F-tier. Auston Trusty was a distressed assets pickup from Philadelphia. Kellyn Acosta and Keegan Rosenberry were too. It can work. But usually it doesn’t, and its a slapdash solution to roster building rather than, you know, investing in the academy, and scouting, and buying top notch DPs and TAM players.
Get a ‘who?’ sponsor for the new stadium name
‘Acrisure’. ‘Investco’. ‘Lower.com.’ ‘KFC Yum! Center.’3
These are not sponsors that inspire the fan base to believe that the club cares about their image. I mean, if the money’s absurd, I guess. But I’ve lived in Pittsburgh eight years now, and I don’t know what Acrisure does. I assume it’s finance? Consulting?
If I have to walk into ‘Trivestrazol Delta-9 topical cream Field at Lenny’s Half-priced Chicken Bowl Stadium’, it will make me very sad - and scared that the Rapids brand is basically dogshit. And I don’t want that to be the case. But it’s possible.
Manager has a bad game/streak and throws the team under the bus
Anthony Hudson answered a post-game question away at Atlanta very badly in May of 2019, saying ‘We’re fighting at the bottom with a bottom group of players.’ That pretty much ended all hope for the team for that season. Hudson was fired a month later.
I hope we never have that level of dysfunction in the team again. Losing is bad. Turmoil and a toxic atmosphere? Probably worse.
Miss the playoffs in 2026 and 2027
We’re halfway there. Yeesh.
F-Tier
Wooden Spoon-level shenanigans
In 2015, 2018, and 2023, the Rapids were flirting with the worst record in MLS. Those were rough years in which the season was effectively over some time in July, and it was hard to rationalize on some days why I’d even bother driving out to Commerce city or tuning in the match on TV.
It’s bad to miss the playoffs, but sensing the team is utterly adrift and every game is ‘not in the face!’ is a whole level worse. It often comes with terrible and embarrassing moments, like Joe Nasco’s red card or Jared Watts’ own goal – although those moments actually happened in 2014 and 2017.
Please, please, let’s not go back to those dark times.
Book a catastrophically bad sponsor that goes bankrupt or stiffs you
As the Rapids deal with Dick’s Sporting Goods sunsets and they work on a new sponsor, the new deal could be anywhere from fabulous to catastrophic.
What does F-tier catastrophic look like?
Enron Field. Sports Authority Stadium. Those are embarrassing. On a similar (maybe worse?) note, the Rapids first-ever kit sponsor, Ciao, was a telecom company that signed a multi-million dollar sponsorship deal but then never came up with any loot after the first $30,000 down. Terrible deal-making, terrible due diligence from Colorado.
A possible related ‘please no’ category is to be affiliated with a scam or an awful immoral company. Herbalife is a ‘multi-level marketing’ company, and the LA Galaxy’s former sponsor. MLMs are very similar to ponzi schemes with a questionable business model that relies heavily on the salespersons being the consumers, too - and that the constant recruiting of new salespersons is financially integral to the survival of the company. Yikes. For more information, check out the ‘LulaRich’ documentary on Amazon Prime.
Some other questionable companies you don’t want affiliated with your sports team: weird sketchy ‘medical’ devices or rhino boner pill ‘supplements’. The basketball stadium in Sacramento was briefly ‘Power Balance Arena’, named for a magical bracelet that cured ailments.
Or there’s also being in a partnership with literal evil. Florida Athletic University almost let their stadium sponsor be the GEO group, which operates private prisons and ICE detention centers with horrible human rights abuses. So, I mean, I guess actually there are worse options than ‘Ciao’.
Throw an R2 guy in at CB and pray for the best
As mentioned above, it looks like Rob Holding is on his way back to jolly old England. That means that the Rapids CBs as of today are Noah Cobb and Loïc Williams. There’s a little depth on the wings with Miguel Navarro, Kosi Thompson, and Jackson Travis at LB and both Reggie Cannon and Keegan Rosenberry at RB - so it’d conceivable that the team just slides a dude over and makes do. But if the team wants a proper 6-foot-plus CB that can clear balls and distribute out of the back, and they don’t sign anyone, then they need to promote internally.
Charlie Harper, Vincent Rinaldi, Jonathan De La Fuente were the primary CBs down the stretch for R2. The Cobras finished 3rd-from-bottom in MLSNP this year, although the team’s league-low 28 Goals For is probably the culprit more so than the defense. It doesn’t look like these three are ready for the big time - only Rinaldi received any senior team call-ups, getting four short-term loan agreements, the final one occurring on September 12 for a game against CF Montreal. He never appeared in a match though - meaning he could become the Colorado Rapids own Moonlight Graham.
Everybody was a kid once that needed a chance. I remember Sam Vines and Cole Bassett toiling with Charlotte Independence before the team gave them a shot. Darren Yapi played a season for the Colorado Springs Switchbacks before he became a 1st division guy. Still, you’d rather do it because a guy is ready rather than because ‘whelp, there’s nobody else to put on the field.’
…
We go into this offseason searching for ways the Rapids could get better. We’ll do some season review type stuff over the next month or two here on the substack. Till then, stay warm, and happy turkey day to all our faithful HTHL listeners and readers.
We talked on the last podcast about whether this will cost Pádraig Smith his job. Matt and I don’t root for people to get fired. We more wonder ‘WILL he get fired?’ I don’t really know, but I do know that whatever Pádraig Smith had hoped to build with the Rapids hasn’t really come to full fruition, and I kind of think he should move on career-wise and take on new challenges. I can’t imagine him building an MLS Cup winner here in Colorado under the conditions KSE had provided him.
In order of magnitude they are: Arsenal FC, LA Rams, the Avalanche, the Nuggets, Arsenal Women, Colorado Rapids, and the Colorado Mammoth. Pity the Mammoth.
I didn’t know that was a thing until I googled. That shouldn’t be a thing.


